Journal of Islamic Studies, 2012, Vol. 23, Issue nr. 3, September 2012

"A provocative and creative effort to make sense of [an ethnic Malay identity that becomes increasingly to be defined in terms of an increasingly monolithic Islam], Hoffstaedter’s account is well worth reading.

"A provocative and creative effort to make sense of [an ethnic Malay identity that becomes increasingly to be defined in terms of an increasingly monolithic Islam], Hoffstaedter’s account is well worth reading.

Hoffstaedter has a real knack for succint, readable theoretical overview, for instance on the ways in which identities are developed, sustained, transformed, and performed.

…an important, bold book."