Monarchy, Democracy and the Supra-constitution
Michael K. Connors and Ukrist Pathmanand (eds)
- Published: 2021
- Pages: 256 pp.
- Series: Asia Insights
- Series number: 10
About the book
- First collection of translations that specifically focus on Thai conservative and royalist ideas.
- Provides first ever English translations of important Thai scholarship that may reshape international debates about Thai democracy and conservatism more generally.
Since Thailand’s prolonged political crisis began with royalist mobilization against prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra in 2005, international observers have been treated to easy clichés about reactionary Thai elites. The chapters in this book invite readers to hold back quick judgement and instead engage with the conservative norms of sections of the middle class, the military, intellectuals and state ideologues.
The opening chapter by the editors provides a historical overview of relevant themes and introduces the translated pieces. It also argues that the concept of a supra-constitution – first introduced by legal scholar Somchai Preechasilpakul in a brilliant lecture to the Pridi Banomyong Institute in 2007 – is a powerful frame for interpreting conservative Thai politics. Somchai’s lecture, now translated here, explains that an unwritten supra-constitution sits above the many failed constitutions that litter Thai history. Like a guiding spirit it contains evolving norms on military and monarchical power which circumscribe democratic political contest.
Other translations include chapters from Nakharin Metrairat’s seminal Thoughts, Knowledge and Political Power in the Siamese Revolution (1990) and the unsurpassed Political Thought of the Thai Military (1990) by Chalermkiat Phi-nuan. Nakarin’s account of vibrant traditionalist thought and Chalermkiat’s interrogation of the cosmological underpinnings of military thought offer profound insights unavailable in English-language scholarship.
On royalism, the translation of Kramol Thongthammachat’s “National Ideology” illuminates how an important state ideologue co-developed a cross-class royalist ideology that emerged as a powerful force after the polarized 1970s. The Thai politician Pramuan Rajunaseri’s sensational book Royal Powers, in part translated here, helped in 2005 to mobilize royalist sentiment against Thaksin.
Work by Saichon Sattayanurak and Pasuk Phongpaichit, both national award-winning scholars, complete the collection. Pasuk’s prescient contribution, originally written in English, warned about new forms of bureaucratic-political patronage emerging during the 1990s that limited civil society activism. Relatedly, Saichon explores how Sino-Thai middle-class dependency on royal power and the judiciary emerges from its historical experience of political insecurity.
This is a must-have reference, one that enables a better understanding of the forces that have shaped Thailand’s democracy struggles.
About the author
Ukrist Pathmanand is Research Professor in Political Science at the Institute of Asian Studies, Chulalongkorn University, and co-author of the acclaimed Thaksinization of Thailand. Both editors have written widely on Thai politics and society, and recently co-authored the article “Thailand’s Public Secret: Military Wealth and the State”, which appears in the Journal of Contemporary Asia.Go to author page
Michael Connors teaches at Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University, PRC in the Department of International Studies and is the author of Democracy and National Identity in Thailand.Go to author page